Well the weird thing is the top cover is loose. But there is 10 caps I replaced, and all of them are built the same way. So the top cover is free to rattle about essentially. and I found them all sitting on top of the capacitor top, so its a bunch of little wells/pools.
They are mallory brand, and there is no scoring on top, I don't think they have a over pressure seal there. I reuse the bases of twist lock capacitors if they are in bakelite, but since they are soldered to a PCB, there is no point and its alot of extra work and possibly a reliability issue IMO.
FP144A under the card board.
If it was scored it would kind of make sense to use the card board as containment, but its not
Reusing the terminals not tied to shield is dodgy too, because they look to be made of a non solderable material inside of the capacitor, so you would need to drill a hole in it anyway to wire it to the center terminal.
And also that bakelite smells like electrolyte, I tried to ultra sonic clean it, wash it in baking soda, bake it at 80C for a few hours, etc.. I think it builds up in the old bakelite. Can't shake the smell. I don't like using the chemical smelling materials if possible., so I only bother if their chassis mount isolated ones (where it requires a mechanical support), so I put new capacitors + silicone on PCB mounted twist locks with a direct connection.
But I am surprised Malory or keithley did not bother cutting the tube to length so they are built the same as the other capacitors. It makes it look dilapidated/dodgy