EEVblog #850 – French Wattway Solar Roadways BUSTED

This time it’s France and their governments ludicrous plan to install 1000km of Solar Roadways from French road building giant Colas Wattway.
Dave breaks down yet again why this is pie-in-the-sky folly.
Forum HERE
Also an update on the 12 months test results of the SolaRoad.nl project in the Netherlands.

Rooftop solar panel output data:
http://pvoutput.org/aggregate.jsp?id=24667
http://pvoutput.org/aggregate.jsp?id=10682
http://pvoutput.org/aggregate.jsp?id=19770

Great article on the French plan HERE

Dave’s other videos:
EEVblog #724 – Home Solar Power System Analysis & Update
EEVblog #681 – More Solar Roadways BULLSHIT!
EEVblog #743 – Solar Roadways Test Results

Be Sociable, Share!

    About EEVblog

    Check Also

    EEVblog #983 – A Shocking Oscilloscope Problem!

    Dave discovered a hidden feature in the new Rohde & Schwarz RTB1004 Oscilloscope – Whack ...

    • Pingback: EEVblog #850 – French Wattway Solar Roadways BULLSHIT | WTS Connects()

    • Pingback: EEVblog #850 – French Wattway Solar Roadways BULLSHIT | Contract Manufacturing Company()

    • Objectif Terre

      Thank you Dave for this really usefull debunking. French people on the “Ministère de l’écologie” in France should pay you for this video as you’ve done the job they should have done themself.

    • Frank Nova

      1- the “at best” is one thing. The at worst is different “grime, traffic, breakage, etc”
      But the AT REAL is even worse: transmission losses, conversion losses to grid AC voltage, etc. If they use the power directly, there will be the separate wiring system for using the DC.

      2- life span is about 10 years, compared to 50 to 100 years for a power plant (coal or nuclear) or a hydro dam. So the capital investment, including removal costs, must be discounted over the lifespan of the system.
      The cost per watt NEVER include the cost of capital in these intellectually dishonest advertisements.

      3- the middle lattitude of France is about 45°, so the angle aspect of the ground, not counting non-linear reflectivity, is about only 70% of a properly aligned (perpendicular to the sun) panel. Of course, this is worst the more north you go, and worse in winter, where the cosine of the angle (i.e. the apparent width projection at the given angle) goes down more and more quickly.
      Now, add the aforementionned ignored interface reflectivity, which goes up with angle, and you get even worse. Overall, the integral (i.e. sum total) of angle as a function of seasonal variations, multiplied by the reflectivity losses at each angle, for a whole year is (my hunch, less than 60%) And this is what Dave noted, comparing the “I believe in Santa Clauss” corporate figures with actual comparable (yet inclined) solar panels.
      I noted that Dave compared angled solar panels with flat roadways. I don’t know if flat roadways power output was given for France’s lattitude (solar angle) and a flat horizontal lay-up on the ground, or if they gave the optimal panel power output (they label them as “up to XXX kW” ) Yeah, up to, but only if installed perpendicularly to the sun when the sun is at its highest point in the sky, where it crosses the least amount of absorbing atmosphere.

      Solar panels at

      http://www.wattwaybycolas.com/en/faq/
      “A Wattway panel lasts as long as conventional pavement, meaning at
      least 10 years depending on the traffic, which speeds up wear. If the
      section is not heavily trafficked – a stadium parking lot for example –
      then Wattway panels can last roughly 20 years.”

    • 【益群网:逆向网赚,不用推广,坐等收钱】

      【系统优势:】
      优势1:静态分红,免费签到,就有钱赚,每日百元
      优势2:十级提成,逆向网赚,什么不干,坐收千万
      优势3:群发软件,名师讲座,百万资源,一键转存
      优势4:百万现金,每月发放,不限人数,上不封顶

      【自动下滑:】
      每人限定五个一级下线,多推荐的自动下滑到一级下线名下
      从而成为推荐者的二级下线。以此类推,直至十级。
      不论这个下线是谁直接推荐的,上线都有提成
      你直接推荐的每个你提成 15 元,上线帮你推荐的每个你提成 1.5 元
      总之,多干多赚,什么都不干,照样有钱赚。

      免费注册网址:

      http://www.cao.eeequn.com/

      评论由软件自动采集群发,如有打扰,屏蔽域名即可

    • Trk

      you have no clue about goverment policy 🙂
      read https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keynesian_economics
      in summary: more work then better 🙂

      BTW: very good video as always

    • muddmike

      Another French government engineering project. Two words: “Maginot Line”.

    • Pingback: Solar Roads: The Next Green Electricity Power Plants? | NooTriX()

    The EEVblog Store generally ships twice a week, on Tuesdays & Fridays, Sydney time.