1
Projects, Designs, and Technical Stuff / Re: Estimating time spent on Miller Plateau (maths)
« Last post by iMo on Today at 02:29:31 pm »I do not have your exact BUK model handy, but basically the LTspice shows some results..
So why do we need AC in our homes? We don't. A house could be supplied with DC power from the mains, and converted to any type of power we could require. Imagine a future where DC power receptacles are installed in a house, at a safe voltage, where electrocution is impossible, and converters simply transform the safe current into anything that is required. Synchronization between solar power and grid power will be much simpler than it is now. It takes some sophisticated equipment to synchronize AC circuits together. With DC, it's a much simpler matter.
A few more questions if you don't mind.
1) I can have a good design and good craftsmanship but if I have poor quality components I will not have a good device. How do I assure quality components? Which manufacturers do I look to?
2) The attached section of the schematic shows all the components that are deleted in the 3610a. It seems as though the section needs a complete redesign with the TIP147. Is there a reference somewhere I can use to help with that?
3) Also in this section Q1,2 will be the Darlingtons. It shows two components next to them D6,7 that look identical to Q1,2. These are not listed in the parts list and Have me a bit confused. What are they? Edit: I have uploaded a PDF of the schematic in the original post. It is much more clear and D6,7 are actually Q6,7. Still not listed parts, so still confused.
If that's too much trouble, just guard-banding the design (design for at worst so-and-so performance, and make everything else handle the best-case result) is fine.
Seems to me, all the more reason to abandon AC distribution all the way down the line.inefficient transformers.This one has to be proved.
From what I was able to find by doing a brief search, typical efficiency of an AC transformer is well over 95%. This is a level that few DC-DC converters can reach, and only when the load matches the operating conditions they were optimized for.
Feasibility of high-voltage switch mode DC-DC converters is another intersting topic. You mentioned a 500 kV DC line, which implies that it should be possible, yet it sounds like a much more challenging task than a good old buzzing bulky AC transformer.
I tend to think that if transformers were more efficient than DC converters, the power companies wouldn't be building so many DC transmission lines.
There are considerably more sources of loss than just transformers. The primary benefit of HVDC is in the transmission e.g. no capacitive loss, no skin effect, no need for three phases, no reactive power issues, lower peak voltages meaning smaller/cheaper insulators etc. You can have more losses in the conversion stages and still end up with better efficiency over long distances.